« Robot Surgery for Prostatectomies | Main | Norwich Deploys Free WiFi »

RFID: is the tag tipping?

rfid-tag.jpgToday there are two reasons to be anxious about RFID: that it may live up to expectations and that it may not.

Civil libertarians are concerned about a wide deployment of RFID and the security of data on tags, and with reason it seems.

In the recent edition of PC Pro, Paul Trotter looks at their concerns. Security experts working with Dutch TV quickly intercepted and cracked encrypted transmissions from a prototype passport’s RFID tag. This allowed access to personal information stored on the tag—a worrying development for the US, where RFID-tagged passports will be available in the next few months.

Food and drinks manufacturers, on the other hand, are concerned that RFID may not be the panacea it seemed. On liquids and metals passive tag read rates can be lower than 40 percent—hardly the basis for comprehensive supply chain management. Similar problems are found in healthcare settings, where signals from tags can also be distorted by the babble of equipment emitting at radio frequency.

Recent enthusiasm for RFID was catalysed by the falling price of passive tags signalling the vision of cheap, ubiquitous tagging. Active RFID tags carrying their own power source could address some of the implementation issues, but they are far more expensive.

As one of a spectrum of wireless techniques, I believe RFID has a role in healthcare. But what role? A few years ago, Gartner placed RFID at the "Peak of Inflated Expectations" on its hype cycle. I think passive RFID is now tipping into the "Trough of Disillusionment", the precursor to new technologies finding their level of practicability. We will see where it ends up.


TrackBack URL for this entry:

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference RFID: is the tag tipping?:

» Upgrade Your Baby, Part 2 from FutureHIT - Speculations on the Future of Health IT
Colin Jervis at FutureHealthIT just put up a post called RFID: is the tag tipping? that gives some great examples of the problems with RFID I speculated about in my recent Upgrade Your Baby post. Here's a couple examples, but [Read More]

» RFID: mark of the beast? from Future Health IT
Mad sorties across the sitting room on legs spinning like Tom's chasing Jerry in a Hanna-Barbera cartoon. Constantly supervising his hosts while giving them lots of affection: a Turkish Angora kitten has arrived at home. The breeder had him RFID... [Read More]

Post a comment

(If you haven't left a comment here before, you may need to be approved by the site owner before your comment will appear. Until then, it won't appear on the entry. Thanks for waiting.)