« High Street Healthcare | Main | Pregnant Robot Teaches Students »

Heathcare IT: helping to collect the evidence

Picture of a judge with scales.I have mentioned my wife often spends evenings scouring medical publication databases for evidence to support her practice as a physiotherapist. This approach has been hammered into her by her tutors. But I have recently read two articles about medical practice that suggest there is further to go.

The first was picked up by the vigilant eHealth blog. An article on BusinessWeek online suggests that only 20-25 percent of medical practice is supported by evidence.

I am told the UK is a leader in implementing evidence-based healthcare. The National Institute for Clinical Excellence (NICE) provides "national guidance on promoting good health and preventing and treating ill health" that can be used by patient and practitioner. Also, the National Electronic Library for Health offers a range of resources, including a link to the Cochrane Library that offers "high quality evidence to inform people providing and receiving care".

However, a second article in New Scientist sees the challenge from another angle. In The Illness Industry Jorg Blech (the science correspondent for Der Spiegel) claims that "cures" for illnesses we did not know we had are converting society into a big hospital.

For instance, Herr Blech highlights the Western tendency to consider menopausal women as ill and to treat them with oestrogen and progesterone based on little clear-cut evidence. The "male menopause" shows a similar pattern, he says, with men now encouraged to use medications like testosterone gel.

In his book Inventing Disease and Pushing Pills Herr Blech quotes Aldous Huxley:

Medicine is so ahead of its time that nobody is healthy any more.

Both of these articles convince me that an integrated national Electronic Health Record, such as NHS Connecting for Health's NPfIT's Spine, has a crucial part in future healthcare. The analysis of anonymised data on patient care and outcomes could lay an even firmer foundation for medical practice.


TrackBack URL for this entry:


Great in theory...

Whilst I wholly agree with promoting evidence-based care; PSIS and SUS will not help there for some time. HIS companies (including the one I work for) are struggling to work out how to get data in, let alone get data out. Getting data out of SUS will be incredibly difficult as no-one has yet worked out a way of efficiently reasoning over collections of interrelated complexly post-coordinated SNOMED data...

A nice review of the articals? especially liked this quotation "Medicine is so ahead of its time that nobody is healthy any more"
More articals about health is here http://healthynewsblog.com

Not true to say menopausal women are ill, but some do have symptoms resulting from normal physiological changes.

These symptoms can be distressing and it is the mitigation of these systems that treatment is aimed at.

Post a comment

(If you haven't left a comment here before, you may need to be approved by the site owner before your comment will appear. Until then, it won't appear on the entry. Thanks for waiting.)